Wednesday, February 26, 2020

Mark Twain & Joan of Arc

MARK TWAIN AND JOAN OF ARC

Eric Leif Davin

In 1994 Laura E. Skandera-Trombley published an interesting work on Mark Twain entitled Mark Twain in the Company of Women.  Her thesis was that “Clemens needed a female audience to whom he could read drafts and receive feedback” (p. 20).  That female audience, headed by his wife, Olivia, reflected “the insights and opinions of individuals who were in their own way as rebellious toward restrictive Victorian society as the Southerner Clemens was toward literary, Brahmin New England or as Huckleberry Finn was toward the slaveholding society of St. Petersburg, Missouri” (p. 25).  To support this thesis, she painstakingly establishes the cultural background of the Langdon family and the town of Elmira from mid-century through the 1890s. 

Based on her research, she contends that, far from endorsing the constraints of upper-middle-class Victorian society, the Langdons, and by extension Olivia Langdon-Clemens, traditionally viewed as Twain’s “censor”, challenged traditional social mores: “Throughout the latter half of the 19th century, the Langdon women and their female relatives and friends continually and knowingly transgressed the boundaries delineating what was considered socially acceptable for women by becoming involved in educational, political, religious, dress, and medical reform” (p. 126).

Of particular interest to her study is Twain’s Personal Recollections of Joan of Arc (1896), which was written, she asserts, specifically to please his family, especially his beloved daughter, Susy, who was by then 23-years old.  As a young woman, “Susy had assumed Olivia’s mantle as didactic monitor” (p. 156).  Even more than her mother, Susy wanted Twain to use “his talents for a higher, moral purpose” (p. 158).  Reading Joan of Arc as a response to the Clemens family’s “reformist beliefs,” Skandera-Trombley sees Joan as “the archetypical WCTU reformer.”  It is likely, she suggests, that Twain was “hiding an allegory of 19th century progressive concerns within the covers of a historical novel” (p. 160). 

However, Skandera-Trombley doesn’t sustain this interpretation to the point of showing us what we might make of the novel if we read it as the allegory she suggests.  Would such a reading help us reconcile Twain’s fondness for this novel with the general neglect it has experienced at the hands of modern scholars?


Tuesday, February 18, 2020

The Home of Edgar Allan Poe

The Home of Edgar Allan Poe


Several years back I visited Edgar Allan Poe’s house in Philadelphia. I was given a group guided tour, which didn’t take long because the house, like most from that antebellum era, was so small. It was basically four rooms, two downstairs and two upstairs, each quite tiny. And a basement. And in this cramped space Poe lived with his young wife and her mother. No doubt the mother had one of the two upstairs bedrooms to herself. Mr. & Mrs. shared the other.

Which means Poe wrote his stories and essays, and performed the busy-work of editing a literary journal, in one of the two Lilliputian rooms on the ground floor.

Perhaps he stored clothes and other personal possessions in the basement. And perhaps, when he was down there, ideas came to him. My guide said that Poe wrote “The Black Cat” while living in the house. I could imagine a black cat entombed behind the wall of that low-ceilinged basement. I could even imagine someone searching that dank and dark pit for a reputed cask of amontillado.

That’s the wonder of the imagination. Unlike physical space, it need not be cramped and confined. It can soar beyond space and time, from the primeval past to the far future and down to black catacombs where dark creatures howl.


Tuesday, February 11, 2020

Reading & Writing-Science Fiction & Fantasy

Reading & Writing-Science Fiction & Fantasy

Can writing be taught? At least at the most basic level of literacy, that of technical competency, the answer is definitely affirmative. Teaching reading and writing is the main business of every society’s schools. How well they actually do it is open to debate, but most people seem to acquire the fundamental rudiments.

Beyond the fundamentals, and especially if we’re talking about creative writing, we enter into the realm of controversy. Perhaps this controversy is as old as writing itself. Perhaps Babylonian scribes argued about this very topic as they pressed their cuneiform script into moist bricks of clay.

There seem to be two basic schools of thought. Some say that every creative writer is basically on his or her own. Creative writing can’t be taught, but it can be learned. And the young would-be creative writer learns the craft by reading a lot, writing a lot, and reading and writing a lot more. After the would-be writer has written perhaps a million words, he or she has probably learned to write at the professional level.

The other school of thought agrees that the young would-be creative writer has to read and write a lot. But it also argues that some aspects of the craft can be taught, thus shortening the arduous path to proficiency.

Practitioners in the field of science fiction and fantasy seem to be in the latter camp. Perhaps this is another aspect of the passionate love affair such aficionados have with their literature. Even in the Thirties, members of groups like the Futurians were mentoring each other on an individual basis in the finer facets of fiction writing. And one of those Futurians, Damon Knight, not only went on to a distinguished career as a fiction writer , but also to an influential career as a critic of the field.

And Damon Knight was also one of the founders in 1956, along with Judith Merril and James Blish, of the annual Milford Science Fiction Writers’ Conference. This was a series of workshops, open only to professional writers, held over eight summer weeks in Milford, Pennsylvania. The purpose was to give professional writers a chance to talk shop and critique each other’s work-in-progress. Other regulars at Milford over the years included Harlan Ellison, Terry Carr, Robert Silverberg, Samuel R. Delany and Kate Wilhelm.

Milford lasted until 1972, the same year that co-founder James Blish moved to Great Britain and, with his wife, founded UK Milford, which continued the tradition overseas. Christopher Priest, Mary Gentle, and Diana Wynne Jones were some of the regulars at UK Milford in the early years.

Damon Knight and Kate Wilhelm were also instrumental in the 1968 founding of the Clarion Science Fiction Writers’ Workshop at Clarion State College, north of Pittsburgh. Now resident at Michigan State University, the Clarion Workshop has produced a noted number of alumni, including Kim Stanley Robinson, Lisa Tuttle, Vonda McIntyre, Ed Bryant, Octavia Butler, and many others.

From the beginning, the mentors at Milford and Clarion went above and beyond in their assistance to their younger colleagues. For example, Harlan Ellison financially supported Octavia Butler out of his own pocket in her early years. He also paid her way to, and tuition for, Clarion in 1970, even though Butler had sold nothing at the time. And, not only did the SF community at Clarion embrace her, but that crucial support was her breakthrough, as Butler was able to sell her very first story the next year, 1971.

In addition to encouraging novice black genre writers such as Octavia Butler and Samuel Delany, the pro writers at Clarion and Milford were also notably welcoming toward beginning female authors. The experience of Kate Wilhelm was typical. In the summer of 1959, not even three years after her debut in the science fiction magazines, she was invited to attend Milford. And there, Wilhelm said in her memoir, Storyteller: Writing Lessons and More from 27 Years of the Clarion Writers’ Workshop, she experienced something she had never before experienced. Male writers, professionals such as Blish and Knight (whom she did not yet know), “treated me and my work seriously in a way no one had done previously.” While such respect and acceptance was unknown to Wilhelm outside the science fiction world, it was the norm inside the science fiction world.

Kate Wilhelm, and so many other graduates of Milford and Clarion, went on to outstanding careers in the field. Their success has given substance to the field’s belief that creative writing, can, indeed, be taught.


Wednesday, February 5, 2020

Sagas, Scrolls, and Sorcery: A Survey of Literature in the Hyborian Age

SAGAS, SCROLLS & SORCERY:
A Survey of Literature in the Hyborian Age
by
Eric Leif Davin

Of all the ancient civilizations, only Atlantis holds more mystery than the Hyborian Age.  Unlike all other vanished societies of which we know, not a single Hyborian archaeological site has been uncovered.  All that is known of these intriguing people is deduced from their surviving literature -- which is itself meager, fragmentary, and obscure -- translated and passed on by later societies.  Even the originals have long since been lost, leaving only reproductions to us.
This, in itself, in not entirely without precedent.  The fame of Sappho, one of history's first known female poets, lives on, but most of her work has not survived.  Aristotle's Constitution of the Athenian People is the sole remnant of the work he, or his assistants, prepared on all the Greek city-states -- and we have this work only by the sheerist accident.  Irreplaceable literary treasures were lost forever in the burning of the Alexandrian library by Caesar's troops.  The Etruscans, who ruled the Italian peninsula before the rise of Rome, left no literature of their own and what we know of them is derived largely from the written records of the Greeks and Romans.  It is believed that the Roman Emperor Claudius, a respected historian in his own time, wrote a comprehensive history of the Etruscans -- but this, too, has vanished utterly.  All else that we know of the Etruscans is gleaned from an archaeological study of their tombs.
Of the Hyborians, however, not even their tombs remain, due to the massive geological upheavals between their time and our own.  Since the close of the Hyborian Age, new lands have risen from the sea and others buried beneath oceans.  Therefore, we must turn to their written records, sketchy though they be, for whatever knowledge we have of them.

THE NEMEDIAN CHRONICLES:
Outside of a few ritualistic and religious inscriptions, the Hyborian record is composed almost entirely of a single historical work, The Nemedian Chronicles.  Although paleolinguists have been able to decipher ancient Nemedian, the fundamental structure of the language remains a mystery.  Pre-dating even early Indo-European sources, no convincing linguistic affinity between Nemedian and other languages has been shown.  Although some scholars have made claims for ancient Nemedian being the progenitor of Gaelic, Finnish, Albanian, and even Basque, no sufficient evidence for this position has been produced.[1]
Nevertheless, much as Latin came to be the universal language of learning in medieval Europe, Nemedian can be presumed to have been the universal language of at least the literate in the Hyborian Age.  One indication of this universality is the central epic of the Chronicles: The Saga of Conan, King of Aquilonia.  While only fragments remain, it is likely that the Chronicles dealt with a wide variety of subjects and heroes -- yet from his story, surely King Conan must have been the greatest hero of a heroic age and he dominates the sections of the Chronicles which have come down to us, as he must have dominated his age.  Indeed, some have speculated that it was the very emergence of Conan as the hero-king of Aquilonia which prompted the genesis of the Chronicles.  Heroic adventures and war have often been an early stimulus to literature; witness The Iliad, The Odyssey, Herodotus' history of the Persian Wars, the Peloponnesian War chronicle of Thucydides and Xenophon's story of the March of the Ten Thousand, which inflamed the minds of Greek readers at the time.[2]

THE PHYSICAL RECORD:
In the Chronicles, Conan often contemptuously refers to writings, most especially sorcerous writings, as "scraps of parchment."[3]  As parchment is the skin of a sheep or goat prepared to be written on, this was probably a common medium of writing among the more barbarous tribes familiar to Conan.  Indeed, the only examples in the Chronicles of writing by the savage Hyperboreans is on parchment.[4]  As such -- particularly in regard to mystic books -- it was probably meant as a term of derision when used by Conan.  Still, it is possible that centers of learning in Nemedia and elsewhere may have retained the use of parchment -- that is, sheepskin -- for various ceremonial writing purposes, much as medieval European universities retained the use of sheepskins to produce academic diplomas.
Nevertheless, the large scale use of sheep or goatskins would have been unfeasible and a primitive form of paper -- most likely papyrus -- was probably more widely used.  Indeed, the Chronicles seem to indicate quite strongly that the basic writing material of Argos and even Aquilonia, two of the most advanced nations of the time, was papyrus.[5]  Papyrus itself (Cyperus papyrus) is a tall sedge plant of the Nile Valley, the pith of which was cut into strips and pressed into a writing material by Egyptian scribes of historic times.  Prior to the cataclysm which ended the Hyborian Age, the Nile was known as the Styx and flowed through what is now the Mediterranean Sea toward what is now known as the Atlantic Ocean.  There is no reason to believe that papyrus did not grow in abundance along the entire length of antiquity's most majestic river and, thus, must have been available in quantity to ancient scholars.
Beyond this, it is conceivable that scribes might have used wax tablets, baked clay tablets, and even carved passages (perhaps meant for posterity) into stone stele -- but of these possibilities we have no written reference and, of course, no surviving physical representatives at all.

THE NEMEDIAN SCHOLARS
Renowned even in their own time for scholarship,[6] the identity of the Nemedian authors of the Chronicles nevertheless remains a mystery.  Much like our own Bible, the Chronicles seem to have been a composite work of which the original authors are anonymous.  Indeed, the very concept of "authorship" -- the "owning" of one's artistic creations -- may have been as foreign to the Nemedian scholars as it was to the nameless artisans whose works accompanied the Egyptian Pharaohs on their journeys to the afterworld.
Still, the names of two Hyborian scholars are handed down to us.  The first of these, Selem the Scholar, was most likely a Nemedian.[7]  Selem the Scholar discovered the fabled Mirror of the Manticore in a tomb excavation on the lower reaches of the river Styx.  This mirror was reputed to have belonged to the Atlantean mirror-wizard Tuzun Thune.  However, Selem the Scholar never returned this mirror to Nemedia for further study, as he and his daughter were overtaken by the outlaw riders of the desert chieftain Khemal Bey south of Khauran and slain.  The mirror itself then vanished from history.
The other scholar of whom we know anything was F'Gahl Ben Akiff, a wizened Turanian captured  as a young man by the white Amazons of Z'harr Hr'ann.[8]  Sahriana, Queen of this uncharted island city-state in the Vilayet Sea, seized him and kept him alive for his esoteric knowledge after his "expeditionary vessel" capsized in a storm.
From what we know of these two scholars, and from more recent scholars of antiquity (such as the Emperor Claudius), we can surmise not only that they tended to be of the nobility, but that they also followed a more activist tradition than present academics.  Their leisured wealth made it possible not only for them to find the time to conduct research in archives and to write, but also frequently leave their ivory towers in search of arcane bits of lore or relics -- much like the fictional "Indiana Jones."
In addition, we have one recorded instance of a "royal scribe," this being to Akter Khan of Zamboula.[9]  This scribe, Uruj, silently recorded the actions and words of his Khan, of Conan, and of the adventuress Isparana at an audition before the Khan in the Zamboulan throne room and at a following banquet.  Indeed, Isparana encouraged Uruj to turn her and Conan's adventures into a "national epic," which might well have been incorporated, therefore, into The Nemedian Chronicles.
The existence of the scribe Uruj leads one to believe that there may have been a scribe class  in ancient Hyboria similar to that of later Egypt.  These scribes and scholars, however, seemed to have concentrated on official recordings and histories of their time.  It is doubtful that a "literature" as we know it consisting of novels, short stories, and the like existed.  This type of literature is associated historically with the rise in Europe of the educated and numerically large middle classes.  Authors then tended to be middle class and wrote for members of their own class.
Ancient societies, however, lacked the economic infrastructure to support such an educated "middle class."  Additionally, the lack of literacy on the part of the populace as a whole would have militated against the spread of a "popular" literature.  We find in the Chronicles, for instance, that Mitralia, a servant girl to Akter Khan's mistress, Chia, could not read.[10]  If a personal servant to a member of the high nobility could not read, it would seem unlikely that the mass of people would be able to read, given the absence of any system of schools and education -- as even historical times have borne out.
Thus, literacy was probably the prerogative of only the privileged classes: The scribes, the priesthood, and perhaps the nobility (though even the nobility of medieval Europe was often illiterate).  This was a situation which would only have contributed to the absence of any mass base for a widespread written literature and to the awe in which this arcane skill was viewed by most people.

THE ORAL TRADITION:
Histories such as The Nemedian Chronicles do not spring into existence full-blown, like Athena from the brow of Zeus.  They are the product not only of a vast and ancient tradition of learning, but of an even more ancient oral tradition.  But, of this Hyborian Age oral tradition, which must have existed, we have scant knowledge.  Clues to the cultural history of the age are so sparse and so scattered that it is difficult to reconstruct any accurate picture.  Thus, there is the danger of anachronistically modernizing ancient life and expression, and so distorting it.
We know little of the songs, dances, march-hymns, devotional prayers, dirges, entertaining narratives and epic sagas, or mimic representations of the Hyborians.  In general, there are few myths or fairy tales which have been handed down to us, although the semi-legendary stories of Atlantis, Valusia, and the Pre-Cataclysm are mentioned in passing by the Chronicles.
What of painting or mosaics?  No examples.  Tapestries?  There must have been many and of intricate quality to judge by the animistic banners of the feuding Aquilonian factions referred to during the War of Liberation.  But, again, no descriptions of them have survived.
And, where is their drama?  Certainly there must have been religious or semi-magical rituals, accompanied by song, which would have evolved into drama.  Indeed, outside of song, drama must have been the most accessible of the "literary" forms for the mass of the populace.  But, again, there are no surviving traces.
Thus, with only scribes, scholars, and priests actually committing words to paper, it would seem that the main form of "literature" available to most people would have been traditional songs and ballads: The eons-old oral literature of the people.  Indeed, ballads have traditionally been the earliest form of "literature," coming before any other form.  Of course, we today cannot know the rhythm of Hyborian ballads, but, fortunately, the Chronicles have preserved six samples of Hyborian lyrics -- the music to which we can only guess.  All of them are associated with the Conan Saga: "The Road of Kings," "Song of the Bossonian Archers," "The Ballad of Belit," "The Song of Red Sonja," and two compositions whose authors are known to us: "The Lament for the King," by Rinaldo of Aquilonia, and "The Dark Valley," by Laza Lanti, both of whom have their own sagas in the Chronicles.[11]
While this is a meager remnant of what must have been a rich oral tradition, nevertheless certain societal attitudes may be gleaned from scraps of poetry and song.  "The Song of Red Sonja"[12] is typical in its exultation of a semi-barbaric world view of rape and pillage:

            All the world's a gore-rimmed sea,
                        Lo, the devil laughs with glee.
            Come and dance then, you with me --
                        Come and caper wild and free!
            With red blood those fires are lit;
                        Hades' smoke is tinged with it!

Most likely, the songs Conan sang when in his cups closely resembled this fragment: moody, bloody, violent.  Indeed, in the second chapter of the Chronicle tale of King Conan known as "The Phoenix on the Sword," the Aquilonian Count Prospero tells Conan that he never heard Cimmerians sing anything but dirges (although this was perhaps meant as humorous exaggeration).
We know, however, that Conan's ancient Cimmeria had a class of "blind bards," a category fairly common among pre-literate peoples, as the "repository" of the oral "literature."  Peoples bereft of the written word tend to compensate with much more powerful memories than we, coming from a literate tradition, are accustomed to, as the Spanish Conquistadores discovered to their amazement among the Aztecs and Incas.  The Cimmerian bards might have carried this ability to even further extremes.  Like blind Homer recounting tales of heroes and glory or West Africa's griots, who retained entire tribal histories in their heads, ancient Cimmeria's blind bards were probably the living libraries of their people.
In the case of Cimmeria, the subject matter was perhaps limited almost entirely to mythic tales of battle and war.  We have but one example, and it is indeed of this nature: According to the saga, Conan was born on a frozen battlefield where Cimmerians vanquished a raiding party from Vanaheim.  Of that battle, Conan once said, "The blind bards have sung the story...around every campfire in Cimmeria."[13]  One can only assume that this sole example of Cimmerian entertainment was typical.
An interesting consideration never elaborated upon in the Conan Saga is the training given these bards.  It is known that they were blind.  Was it an aspect of Cimmerian society to orient warriors blinded in battle or boys blinded in youthful accidents toward the bardic calling?  If so, it would seem this tradition is a welcome humanitarian exception to the assumption that Cimmerian society held no place for the weak and lame.
Of course, an opposite and somewhat ghoulish interpretation, propounded by some younger scholars in the field, is that the bards were chosen in youth by some unknown logic and deliberately blinded and trained in their imposed profession -- much as the Catholic Church at one time castrated young boys to preserve their youthful voices for church choirs.  While the Christian tradition at least forces us to consider this grisly possibility, we must admit there is no evidence to support this rather extreme hypothesis.
In his youth, the ballads of Cimmeria's blind bards would have been Conan's sole exposure to a "literary" tradition.  While a few other barbaric peoples, such as the Picts and, possibly, the Vanir, had no written language, Cimmerians seem to have been unique among Hyborian Age barbarians in viewing writing as a mystic skill to be held in dread and revulsion.[14] As a young man, Conan once came upon a wizard-king's sword in a tomb guarded by hieroglyphics.  He is said to have exclaimed at the time, "The Elders of our tribe have whispered of this magic thing called writing..."[15]  His response highlights the superstitious awe in which this skill was viewed and the association of writing with the despised handiwork of wizards goes far in explaining why Cimmeria never developed a written language, despite bordering upon Aquilonia, the most advanced nation of the time.
Yet this very absence of a written language may have enriched Cimmerian cultural life in other ways.  As the linguist Guenon was fond of pointing out, speech is nomadic in nature -- but "literature," as we know it, the artistic creation of an individual, belongs to the city.  Myths, however, the subject matter of the oral tradition from Homer to Beowulf, arise from "the folk." Their emergence and elaboration occur early in the oral traditions of a culture; they do not spring from the speculations of the individual.  "Literature" -- by which we now are indicating written expression -- is too individual, too deliberate, too permanent for the sustenance of myth.
Thus, Cimmeria was truly a land of myth and legend.  It was a land where the Frost Giant's Daughter still danced among men and the Red God stalked the battlefields.  Illiterate Cimmeria may have been, in a sense, more "religious" than any urban and literate society.  Being closer, more a part of mythology himself, Conan may well have viewed his principal god Crom as a supernatural being -- yet, nonetheless, a vital, living, breathing, existing god who yet walked among men on the icy hills of Cimmeria.
While Cimmerians avoided writing, such was not the case of other northern societies, including even the  primitive Hyperboreans.  We know the latter possessed a runic or hieroglyphic writing, as exhibited on the forehead of the mammoth skull demarking the border between Hyperborea and The Border Kingdom.  The painted runes on this landmark, well-known in antiquity, warned, "The gate of Hyperborea  is the gate of death to those who come hither without leave."[16]  Obviously, not only did the savage Hyperboreans thus possess an alphabet, but this was shared with the barbaric Border Kingdom -- else the warning was useless.
Additionally, at least some among the Hyperboreans, perhaps tribal "scribes," also understood the writing of other, more advanced societies as well -- something never mastered by the Cimmerians.  We can see this, for instance, in the "parchment" message "crudely scrawled in Aquilonian," left for King Conan by the Hyperboreans after kidnapping his son, Prince Conn.[17]
One puzzling postscript to the deliberate illiteracy of Cimmerian society was Conan's knowledge of written Thelic, an ancient language dating to Pre-Cataclysm times.[18]  Scholars know nothing of Thelic -- where it came from, who spoke it, what it looked like.  We know only that it was the language of Conan's grandmother and that Conan could read it in adulthood.  Was Conan's grandmother a war captive carried off by his grandfather?  Did she, instead, come willing to Cimmeria?
And when and where -- after his illiterate childhood and adolescence -- did Conan belatedly learn to read his grandmother's language?  Indeed, given the superstitious apprehension with which Cimmerians viewed writing, how did Conan's nameless grandmother even preserve her knowledge and overcome his superstitious resistance to pass it on to her grandson?  Provocative as these questions are, they must remain forever a blank page in the history of Hyborian literature.

RELIGIOUS AND MYSTIC WRITINGS:
Of course, the central epic of The Nemedian Chronicles is the saga of King Conan.  Within this epic there are references to written works dealing with only two other subjects: Religion and sorcery (though perhaps some would see them as one subject in ancient societies).  It seems reasonable to assume, therefore, that these subjects were of central importance to whoever authored the Chronicles, if not to the society itself.
Of the religious works, the text of none remain.  Indeed, the Chronicles make mention of only one such work, the holy book of the Azweri known as The Book of the Death God, but of its contents nothing is known.  The total obliteration of Hyborian religious works has long been a frustration to researchers and greatly hampers any true understanding of how Hyborians viewed themselves in relation to their cosmos and their gods.
Perhaps the most intriguing elements in the lost literature of the Hyborian Age, however, are the fabulous writings of the wizard-scholars of that time.  Noted scientist and science fiction writer Arthur C. Clarke has stated that there is no difference between magic and a highly advanced technology to one who doesn't understand the technology.  Seen in this light, ours was a magical society to  members of South Pacific Cargo Cults during and shortly after World War II.  Yet ours is also a society which has lost the understanding of a much different technology -- the ancient science of sorcery, of which gypsy fortune tellers are only a pathetic reminder.
It is now acknowledged that ancient Hyboria was more advanced than our own age in the realm of sorcery.  But, alas, The Nemedian Chronicles can only name the authors of that age's Six Mystic Works; it cannot reveal their long-lost contents.  None of the Six Mystic Works have titles per se.  Perhaps this was forbidden for sorcerous reasons.  They are known, rather, by the names of their authors.  Foremost of the ancient works was The Book of Skelos, closely followed in magnitude by The Books of Vathelos the Blind.  The four remaining texts were The Tomes of Sabatea, The Book of Shuma-Gorath, The Scroll of Amendarath, and The Book of Guchupta of Shamballah. 
Virtually nothing is known of these wizards but that two were blind: Vathelos the Blind, from his name, was sightless, while Skelos, the most important sorcerous author, is also known to have been blind.[19]  As the Chronicles detail not a single instance of a practicing wizard being blind, one might guess that Skelos and Vathelos were elder wizards who had "retired," perhaps even due to their blindness, to the preservation and transmission of their knowledge.
An abiding mystery to scholars of Hyboria's literature is why only magical works appear to be in what we today know as "book" form.  With the exception of sorcerous tomes, all writings of the Hyborian Age seem to have been in the form of scrolls.  We know, for instance, that all the important documents of Aquilonia, one of the most progressive and powerful nations of the age, were in scroll format: Treasury accounts, legal petitions, deeds and wills, and so on.[20]
Yet, although even blind Skelos is described by Conan as the author of "sorcerous scrolls,"[21] clearly the physical act of writing by wizards was done, perhaps for ritualistic reasons, in what we today know as the offspring of Gutenberg: Books -- rather than in scrolls.[22]
The Chronicles repeatedly refer to magical works as "iron-bound books."  Both the works of Skelos and Vathelos the Blind are described thus.  In addition, Shu-Onoru, wizard of Kheshatta, Stygia's City of Magicians, refers to his wizardly texts as "my iron-bound books."[23]  Indeed, with the single exception of the possibly fraudulent Book of Guchupta of Shamballah, which is ambiguously described as an "ancient python-bound tome,"[24] all Hyborian sorcerous works are referred to as "iron-bound books."
Originally, scholars believed this intriguing phrase from the Chronicles referred to sorcerous scrolls which were deposited in iron chests for either mystic reasons or for safe keeping.  A more recent interpretation, however, which is gaining credence, is that the phrase means exactly what it says: That all truly sorcerous books actually were books, as we know them, rather than scrolls, and had borders and hinge-bindings of iron clasps.
An excerpt from the Conan Saga which had long hindered this interpretation was the tale of "The Children of Rhan."[25]  Near Surhon, "a city just east of Vanaheim" (in the Asgardian wilderness?), Conan discovered an ancient Pre-Cataclysmic ship dating back to when Vanaheim was covered by waters.  Inside the rotting artifact, Conan found the ship's log -- the only such reference to a ship's log in the Chronicles.  This log -- known as The Rhan Log  -- was shaped like a book rather than a scroll.  This is the only description in the Chronicles of any written work outside of a sorcerous text being in "book" format.
For many years, the existence of The Rhan Log was viewed by one school of scholars as indicative of a widespread use of the book format, contemporary with and possibly supplanting scrolls over time.  However, it is now possible to place The Rhan Log firmly within the mystic tradition, for there is reason to believe that Ehestes Rhan, the pirate captain who kept the log -- was a sorcerer!  Indeed, that very accusation was made against Capt. Rhan by his own men as their justification for their mutiny against him after one of them discovered "a few tomes of ancient incantations" in his cabin.  Rhan's crew marooned him along with his "books" of "ancient incantations" and the sorcerous-appearing log as well.
The Rhan Log itself reveals that Capt. Rhan followed the solitary path of the wizard-scholar.  "I have studied the teachings of Set and Mhur!" Rhan claimed.  "I pray to the Dark Ones -- to the Great Goat Gods and their brethren."  The Conan Saga then details how the marooned and now openly wizardous Capt. Rhan created the "Children of Rhan" -- beautiful young girls who metamorphosed into ravening monsters, eventually destroying Capt. Rhan's crew when they returned.
Accordingly, it was only natural that a pirate captain-turned-apprentice wizard would have sorcerous "books" in his possession -- nor is it strange that his personal diary, or "log," should have been of the same nature.  Why else would his superstitious crew have abandoned the ship's very log along with their captain had it not been of a "sorcerous" appearance?  Thus, it seems there may have been a certain proscription upon the very use of the book format -- as we know it in the post-Gutenberg world -- as "evil," "unholy," or, simply, unlucky.
This would not be the only time an ancient people had working models of a "technology" which they never utilized.  Scholars have hypothesized about an Industrial Revolution occurring in ancient Greece, which knew of and demonstrated the principle of the steam engine.  The ancient Mayans knew of and used the wheel on many vehicles -- all children's toys.  The wheel was never adapted by the American Indians for adult use.
But, just as historians will never adequately explain the failure of ancient Mayans to fully utilize the wheel, it is doubtful we will ever explain the exclusion of the book format from the secular writings of the Hyborian Age to our satisfaction.  Like the people themselves, it remains a mystery, lost in the mists of time.

THE MAKING OF A SORCERER:
But, how did one become a wizard in ancient Hyboria?  A possibility might have been by starting as a priest fallen from grace, or as a renegade scholar lusting for "profane," meaning "unholy," knowledge and power, much like our own Dr. Faustus.  Indeed, there is reason to believe there may actually have been a close interchange between "profane" and "sacred" scholars.  We know, for instance, that the Ibis Priest Karanthes, once of "wizard-haunted Stygia", chose exile among the scholars of Nemedia -- where he sought the knowledge of long-dead Skelos.[26]
But, if such was the case, the pursuit of such knowledge must have been primarily an individual, solitary quest -- as was that of Dr. Faustus.  This would help explain the vital importance the Chronicles say wizards placed upon their books, these being their only guides and mentors.  Indicative of the great value they placed upon these texts is the story of the Zul brothers, wizards both.[27]  Akter Khan, Satrap of Zamboula, ordered the arrest and execution of Hisarr Zul and his brother Tosya Zul for plotting against his throne.  They fled Zamboula in haste, regretfully abandoning a 15-year collection of sorcerous texts.  The only remnant of their magical tomes which they could rescue -- and presumably, therefore, their most precious wizardly accoutrement -- was the single page which they possessed from The Book of Skelos.
In addition, the Chronicles mention the self-education of two minor wizards, Zafra of Zamboula and the black warrior Zula -- the latter, actually, a novice.  We know that Zula, Conan's warrior companion, had certain minor magical abilities.  These he acquired, he stated, from stealthily  studying, as a sort of unauthorized "sorcerer's apprentice," the works of Skelos, Vathelos the Blind, and "time-lost Shuma-Gorath" in the library of his wizard master.[28]
Corroboration that the pursuit of sorcerous knowledge was isolated and solitary is found in the career of the wizard Zafra of Zamboula, the only "official" city wizard mentioned in the Chronicles (although there are, of course, several other instances of a mage allying himself with a king or ruler).  Zafra, "a mere court magician," gained all he knew from his private perusal of "the unholy Book of Skelos, the evil-reeking Tomes of Sabatea, and the forbidden texts of Vathelos the Blind."[29]  One might even go further and say that his was a clandestine study, as well, for he painstakingly concealed the contents of his books even from his confidante and mistress, Chia, the Khan's concubine.
Zamboula must have been, at least at this time, a major center of sorcerous scholarship for Zafra, "a mere court magician," to have had access to all the aforementioned texts.  Remember, also, this is the same city and time in which the exiled Zul brothers boasted of owning a page from The Book of Skelos, as well as many other mystic writings.
Nevertheless, one can deduce from the references to Zafra's studies that sorcery did not reign unchecked in Zamboula -- even though it may have had the Khan's blessings.  Someone or some thing labelled The Book of Skelos "unholy," The Tomes of Sabatea "evil," and succeeded in having the texts of Vathelos the Blind actually forbidden (the only such instance in the Chronicles).

SORCEROUS SUBJECTS:
What was the nature of the magics dealt with by these long vanished "unholy" tomes?  Again, we can only guess.  It is possible that The Book of Guchupta of Shamballah discussed in some fashion the quest for eternal life, for Thulandra Thuu, the nominal "servant" of Aquilonia's King Numedides, sought its secret therein.[30]  However, Thuu dismissed Guchupta's work as useless, so eternal life, after all, may not have been its theme, or the book may not have even dealt with the mystic arts after all!  Thuu also consulted The Scroll of Amendarath for the correct positioning of the planets, implying that the work was of an astrological nature and, thus, perhaps relatively minor.
However, the major tomes referred to again and again by sorcerous students were the books of the two blind seers Vathelos and Skelos.  Of the two, The Book of Skelos seems to have been the major work.  The exact nature of its contents is, of course, unknown, but it must have been the premier compilation of spells and general magical principles.  Thus, for instance, Zafra of Zamboula states that he cannot ensorcel more than two swords at a time because, "It's a Law of Skelos."[31]
Of The Book of Skelos, the Chronicles say, "The direst whispers you have heard are true -- for, it contains dark secrets handed down from untold ages, before Atlantis sank...secrects to blast men's eyes -- or tear their souls asunder!"[32]  Of course, the Chronicles then go on to say that Conan disparaged this description as merely a "tradesman's pitch."
Nonetheless, a single page from a copy of The Book of Skelos, such as the Zul brothers possessed, was deemed a "treasure of treasures."  In Conan's quest for one of those dread treasures, the Chronicles provide a tantalizing glimpse of the language and nature of The Book of Skelos.
A "page" looked like a scroll, rather than a page as we know it.[33]  The language in which the book was written appears to have been a hieroglyphic language.  The one image which scholars are certain was used in the text is that which the later Egyptians termed The Eye of Horus.[34]  The Eye of Horus is a strange glyph to find in a tome of the Dark Arts, for Horus was the Egyptian god of light who overcame darkness and possessed the life-giving power of the sun.  Yet, while we do not understand the presence of this glyph in The Book of Skelos, it might perhaps give us a clue to the ethnicity of Skelos himself.
Linguists generally consider the ancient Egyptian language to have been a remote descendant of Stygian which, in turn, evolved out of ancient Acheronian.  But, besides the linguistic clue, the nature of archaic Acheron itself argues for an Acheronian origin of Skelos.  Grim Acheron was a land of darkness ruled by wizard-kings -- a most appropriate cradle for the most sorcerous book of all.
It is in The Book of Skelos that we also learn of The Hand of Nergal, a mystic amulet bringing its bearer two gifts: Power beyond all limit -- then, death beyond all despair.  The Chronicles describe The Hand of Nergal at some length, the only such detailed example retrieved from The Book of Skelos.  The Hand looks like,

a clawed hand carven of old ivory, worked all over with weird glyphs in a forgotten tongue.  The claws clasp a sphere of shadowy, dim crystal....They say it fell from the stars into the sunset isles of the uttermost west, ages upon ages before King Kull rose to bring the Seven Empires beneath his single standard.  Centuries and ages beyond thought have rolled across the world since first bearded Pictish fishermen drew it dripping from the deep and stared wonderingly into its shadowy fires!  They bartered it to greedy Atlantean merchants, and it passed east across the world.  The withered, hoary-bearded mages of elder Thule and dark Grondar probed its mysteries in their towers of purple and silver.  The serpent men of shadow-haunted Valusia peered into its glimmering depths.  With it, Kom-Yazoth whelmed the Thirty Kings until the Hand turned upon him and slew him.[35]

The Book of Skelos, however, also speaks of a counter-talisman to this Demon Hand -- The Heart of Tammuz.  Later Tammuz was to evolve into the Babylonian god of vegetation who was reborn each Spring and was the husband or lover of Ishtar, the principal Babylonian deity.  This incorporation of Babylonian -- and Egyptian -- symbols of life and light into the teachings of The Book of Skelos, however, merely serves to reinforce the accepted interpretation that this work was a tome of general principles.  Therein, one could find the uses of "good" magics -- as well as the mis-uses of "evil" magics.
Finally, it seems, The Book of Skelos was itself an actual vessel of sorcery, as well as a transmitter of sorcerous knowledge.  The Chronicles relate that Conan failed in his quest for the Skelos page, as it spontaneously burst into flames once he possessed it.[36]
This posthumous protection of things Skelos seems also to have extended to the mage himself.  While Conan's ultimate fate is lost to history, we do know the final resting place of Skelos.[37]  The pirate Belit, beloved of Conan, seems to have cached her plunder on a "nameless isle" far to the west of the Shemitish coast, an isle not to be found on any Hyborian map.  This isle scholars have come to call Skelos Island, for it was here that demons were set to haunt the Temple of the Toad and protect the Well of Skelos, wherein the long dead remains of the Acheronian sorcerer were laid.  The demon-guarded Grave of Skelos demonstrates, if nothing else could, the power of Skelos himself -- most illustrious of ancient wizards!





[1]c.f. The Nemedian Connection, Robert E. Howard, Hyperbolic Press: Cross Plains, Tx., 1934. 
[2]c.f. The Conan Chronicle, L. Sprague de Camp, Gnome Press: N.Y., 1954.
[3]Conan the Barbarian, #67.  See also, "Battle of the Barbarians," Red Sonja, #7, Marvel Feature, Marvel Comics.
[4]"The Witch of the Mists," King Conan, #1, Marvel Comics.
[5]"When Madness Wears the Crown," Savage Sword of Conan, #49.  During Conan's War of Liberation in Aquilonia, the spy Quesado sent all his messages to Thulandra Thuu on papyrus.
[6]c.f., "He Who Waits in the Well of Skelos," Conan the Barbarian, #73, Marvel Comics.
[7]"Mirror of the Manticore," Savage Sword of Conan," #58, Marvel Comics.
[8]"The Temple of the Tiger," Savage Sword of Conan, #62.
[9]"The Eye of Erlik, Part II," Savage Sword of Conan, #57, p. 42.
[10]"The Eye of Erlik, Part II," p. 21.
[11]c.f., "The Last Ballad of Laza Lanti," Conan the Barbarian, #45.  Laza Lanti was a companion to Conan during his wanderings while Rinaldo participated in a conspiracy against King Conan after Conan's ascension to the Aquilonian throne.
[12]Conan the Barbarian, #24.
[13]"The Corridor of Mullah-Kajar," Conan the Barbarian, #117.
[14]Among more recent "barbarian" cultures, however, this is not so uncommon.  Among the Vikings, a "rune" was both a symbol used in writing as well as a "secret."  Indeed, our very word "grammar" and "grimorie," meaning "enchantment," have the same root.
[15]"The Shadow of the Tomb," Conan the Barbarian, #31.
[16]"The Witch of the Mists," p. 30.
[17]"The Witch of the Mists," p. 17.
[18]c.f. "The Children of Rhan," Savage Sword of Conan, #64.
[19]c.f. "The Hand of Nergal," by Robert E. Howard and Lin Carter in Conan, Robert E. Howard, L. Sprague deCamp, and Lin Carter, Lancer Books: N.Y., 1967, pp. 179-180.
[20]"Conan the Liberator," Savage Sword of Conan, #52.
[21]c.f. "He Who Waits in the Well of Skelos."
[22]The possible exception is The Scroll of Amendarath, which may have been in book format despite its title or may have been considered more an astrological almanac than a sorcerous tome, per se.  See the discussion below of Thulandra Thuu's consultation of this text.
[23]"Of Swordsmen and Sorcerers!" Conan the Barbarian, #85.
[24]"When Madness Wears the Crown."
[25]Savage Sword of Conan, #64.
[26]"Beware the Sacred Sons of Set!" Marvel Feature Presents Red Sonja, #6.
[27]"The Stalker Amid the Sands," Savage Sword of Conan, #54.
[28]"Of Swordsmen and Sorcerers!"
[29]"The Eye of Erlik, Part II," p. 8.
[30]"When Madness Wears the Crown," p. 9.
[31]"The Sword of Skelos," Savage Sword of Conan, #56.
[32]"Daggers and Death-Gods!", Conan the Barbarian, #66.
[33]c.f. the illustration in "Daggers and Death-Gods!"
[34]c.f. "Daggers and Death-Gods!, Part II," Conan the Barbarian, #67.
[35]"The Hand of Nergal,"  pp. 179-180.
[36]"Daggers and Death-Gods!, Part III," Conan the Barbarian, #68.
[37]c.f. "He Who Waits in the Well of Skelos."